Mystery games are not often found among the mainstream triple-A titles for the PS4, but there are still plenty of gems out there to be experienced if you’re a fan of the genre.
If you enjoy solving problems and unravelling ambiguities, read on for the 10 best mystery games for the PS4.
10. Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments is an adventure mystery games developed by Frogwares and released in 2014.
The game takes place in late 19th Century London and is heavily inspired by the original stories of Arthurs Conan Doyle’s detective fiction series. There are six different cases to be solved throughout the game, and to do so players must visit different locations to discover clues and explore crime scenes to put the pieces of the puzzle together.
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments feels like an authentic part of Arthur Conan Doyle literature, and is, undoubtedly, one of the best mystery games for the PS4 to play right now.
9. The Sexy Brutale
The Sexy Brutale is a game unlike any other for the PS4 and features a unique and quirky style of animation that lends itself well to the mystery genre.
Inspired by the cult-classic Groundhog Day, the game involves a 12-hour time loop in a casino mansion, in a period of time following the events of an annual party called the The Sexy Brutale. The playable character, Boone, has broken free of the time loop and must save the other party revellers from their deaths by gathering information from clues and hints.
The Sexy Brutale is one of the more stylish games within the genre and, coupled with an interesting gameplay concept, this game easily makes for one of the best mystery games around right now.
8. Agatha Christie: The ABC Murders
Agatha Christie: The ABC Murders is a point-and-click mystery game that was developed by Artefacts Studio and released in 2016.
In this game, you take on the role of the famous detective Hercule Poirot as you try to investigate clues that will lead to the identification of a mysterious serial killer – the “ABC” killer. Both fans of mystery games and of the Agatha Christie detective novels will love this game. Despite its brevity, the game is addictive and fun, and should definitely be investigated if you’re looking for the best mystery games for the PS4.
7. The Shapeshifting Detective
The Shapeshifting Detective is a supernatural murder mystery game that was released in 2018 and takes on a full-motion video (FMV) format.
In the game, you take on the role of a detective who has the ability to morph into other characters and, consequently, unlock different dialogues with certain characters and unravel the mystery of the murder of Dorota Shaw.
The supernatural-noir aesthetic and the FMW format add a unique twist to the mystery genre and make The Shapeshifting Detective a must-try for those looking for great mystery games for the PS4.
6. The Witness
The Witness is a 2016 puzzle game by game developer Thekla, Inc. The game received overwhelming positive feedback upon its release, with critics praising its challenging yet engaging puzzles and the huge number of mysteries to unravel.
The game is played from first-person perspective and follows an unnamed character as he navigates a large island solving various mysteries and puzzles. The island is split up into different categories of puzzles, all of which must be conquered to get to the final destination – the mountain.
The Witness brilliantly interweaves first-person gameplay with complex puzzles in a way that keeps you engaged throughout. This is a mystery game that will challenge you and keep you entertained for days.
5. L.A. Noire
L.A. Noire is a detective action-adventure game that was developed by Team Bondi. The game was initially released in 2011 before being remastered for eighth-generation consoles in 2017.
The game features an open-world environment in which players can explore 1940s Los Angeles as an officer of the LAPD. Played from third-person perspective, you must solve cases by investigating crime scenes, searching for clues, and interrogating suspects. The game also allows players to free roam the open world environment and take part in various other activities.
Despite being a remaster, L.A. Noire is one of the best mystery games for the PS4 and is a game that will keep you engrossed from beginning to end.
4. The Wolf Among Us
The Wolf Among Us is a graphic-adventure mystery game released in 2013 by developer Telltale Games – the same game developers as the awesome The Walking Dead game series. The Wolf Among Us is an episodic interactive game that is based on the Fables comic book series.
The game is split into five different episodes, in which you play as protagonist Bigby Wolf, the sheriff of Fabletown, a secret community of fairy tale characters. As Bigby, you are tasked with investigating crimes throughout the area, and the decisions that you make during these investigations will alter the events that take place later in the game.
The Wolf Among Us is stylish and charming, and its unique world makes it easily one of the top mystery games for the PS4.
3. The Vanishing of Ethan Carter
The Vanishing of Ethan Carter is an adventure-mystery game with elements of horror. It was released in 2014 and developed by The Astronauts.
In the game, players can explore an open world environment in order to solve the mystery surrounding the deaths of the Carter family. The player has paranormal abilities which can be used upon locating a dead body in order to piece together the events. The plot is engaging and unique and, along the journey, you will seek the answers to numerous questions – who exactly was Ethan Carter? And what is the truth about the protagonist and paranormal investigator’s existence?
This is one of the best mystery games for the PS4 right now, and well worth trying out.
2. Broken Sword 5: The Serpent’s Curse
Broken Sword 5: The Serpent’s Curse is the fifth instalment of the cult series by Revolution Software and was received positively upon its release in 2013. The game was largely funded by a Kickstarter campaign, in which it raised more that $750,000.
The game follows the same point-and-click mystery adventure format as previous instalments in the series. Players follow the story of George Stobbart and Nicole Collard as they investigate a mysterious painting that takes them on a journey to Paris, Catalonia, and many other places.
The Serpent’s Curse is visually stunning and has an engaging plotline to match – it is definitely one of the best mystery games for the PlayStation 4 available right now.
Firewatch is an adventure mystery game that was developed by Campo Santo and released in 2016. The game was one of the surprise success stories of 2016 and received universal critical acclaim.
The game follows the story of Henry, a fire lookout based in the Shoshone National Forest. Henry must explore the area in order to investigate strange happenings and unravel the mystery of a dark entity that seems to be haunting his patrol. The game is played from first-person perspective and features a walkie talkie to interact with other characters in the game.
Firewatch is an enjoyable mystery game for the PS4 that has an immersive and engaging gameplay experience. This is definitely one to try if you’re looking for the best PS4 mystery games.
Get in Touch
I hope you enjoyed reading about the 10 best mystery games for the PS4. If you did, you might like to check out our article about some of the best free internet games around righ now.
What is your favorite mystery game? Let us know in the comments section and join our Blog of Games gaming blog community. If you have any questions, please get in touch below or contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org